Best Seafood in Winter Park, FL (2026): 7 Local Picks

Looking for the best seafood in Winter Park? Start with Winter Park Fish Company for shrimp and grits and fresh fish to cook at home, then Atlantic Beer & Oyster in its hidden garden off Park Avenue for oysters and daily ceviche. Steakhouses and a Cajun kitchen round out the list.

7 picks · Updated October 2026

1
Winter Park Fish Company

Restaurant, $$
Styled like a Key West fish house, this casual spot does pecan-crusted trout, fish tacos and crab cakes, and sells fresh fish portions to cook at home.
- Seafood
- Southern
- Lunch
- Dinner
Call Winter Park Fish Company Website for Winter Park Fish Company (opens in a new tab)Directions to Winter Park Fish Company (opens maps)
2
Atlantic Beer & Oyster

Restaurant in Park Avenue
Oysters, peel-and-eat shrimp and a ceviche made daily, served in a garden off Park Avenue. It is the relaxed Winter Park choice for a raw bar afternoon.
- Seafood
- Burgers
- Cocktails
- Happy hour
Call Atlantic Beer & Oyster Website for Atlantic Beer & Oyster (opens in a new tab)Directions to Atlantic Beer & Oyster (opens maps)
3
Blu on the Avenue

Restaurant in Park Avenue
Blu on the Avenue is a Park Avenue seafood restaurant in Winter Park serving sushi, salads, sandwiches, entrées and brunch, with dishes prepared to order.
- Seafood
- Sushi
- Sandwiches
- Brunch
Website for Blu on the Avenue (opens in a new tab)Directions to Blu on the Avenue (opens maps)
4
Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen

Restaurant
Cajun and New Orleans staples on Aloma Avenue bring a Gulf Coast angle to Winter Park seafood, with live music and a Sunday brunch when you want a longer meal.
- Seafood
- Southern
- Cocktails
- Live music
Call Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen Website for Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen (opens in a new tab)Directions to Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen (opens maps)
5
The Chapman

Restaurant in Park Avenue
The Chapman is a Park Avenue restaurant in Winter Park serving brunch, lunch and dinner. Its menu highlights prime steaks, Florida seafood, fresh pasta, salads and cheeses built around local produce, with craft cocktails and wine.
- Seafood
- Steakhouse
- Italian
- Brunch
Call The Chapman Website for The Chapman (opens in a new tab)Directions to The Chapman (opens maps)
6
Corner Chophouse

Restaurant in Hannibal Square
Prime beef is the draw in Hannibal Square, but local seafood gets equal billing on the menu, which makes it a smart choice for a dressier surf-and-turf dinner.
- Seafood
- Steakhouse
- Cocktails
- Dinner
Call Corner Chophouse Website for Corner Chophouse (opens in a new tab)
7
BoVine Steakhouse

Restaurant in Park Avenue
BoVine's seafood and lobster bisque on Park Avenue are a fallback for groups who also want steak or sushi, and it stays open late.
- Seafood
- Steakhouse
- Sushi
- Breakfast
Call BoVine Steakhouse Website for BoVine Steakhouse (opens in a new tab)Directions to BoVine Steakhouse (opens maps)

Where to eat seafood in Winter Park

For seafood as the main event, Winter Park Fish Company is the casual Key West-style fish house with fried and grilled plates, and Atlantic Beer & Oyster is a small shack with patio seating in the garden off Park Avenue. Blu on the Avenue sits right on Park Avenue with sushi and happy hour oysters.

For a dressier evening, The Chapman features Florida fish on Park Avenue and Corner Chophouse brings local seafood to Hannibal Square, a short walk west across the tracks. Tibby's on Aloma Avenue is the pick for Cajun and New Orleans dishes, with live music and a Sunday brunch.

Tips for seafood in Winter Park

Atlantic Beer & Oyster and Blu both run happy hours, which are the easiest way to try oysters without a full bill. Winter Park Fish Company also sells fresh fish portions to take home, a handy option on busy nights. Weekend parking on Park Avenue is tight, so give yourself extra time or use the side streets. To choose, match the place to the occasion: Winter Park Fish Company for a family dinner, Atlantic Beer & Oyster for drinks and small plates, and The Chapman or Corner Chophouse when you want to dress up. In summer, eat on the patios after sunset.

About this list

Every place here is a locally run business in Orange County with its own website, which we checked for hours, menus and contact details. We leave national chains off our best-of lists and favor places with a clear specialty.

This page covers 7 seafood restaurants in Winter Park. You'll find them in Park Avenue and Hannibal Square.

What comes up again and again on their menus and websites: Sushi, Catering, Happy hour, Prime steaks and Private dining.

About Winter Park

Winter Park sits just north of Orlando and is known for Park Avenue, Rollins College, its chain of lakes and brick streets. The city has a dense cluster of independent restaurants, boutiques, salons and professional offices.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best seafood restaurant in Winter Park?

Winter Park Fish Company is the top casual pick, with shrimp and grits, pecan-crusted trout, crab cakes and fish tacos in a relaxed fish house setting. For oysters and a drink, Atlantic Beer & Oyster off Park Avenue is the best spot. The Chapman and Corner Chophouse cover a more upscale seafood dinner.

Where can I get oysters in Winter Park?

Atlantic Beer & Oyster is the dedicated oyster bar, with fresh oysters, daily ceviche and peel-and-eat shrimp in a small garden setting off Park Avenue. Blu on the Avenue also runs happy hour oysters in the afternoon and late at night. Both pair well with local draft beer or a coastal cocktail.

Can I buy fresh fish to cook at home in Winter Park?

Yes. Winter Park Fish Company sells retail portions of fresh fish alongside its restaurant menu, so you can eat lunch and pick up dinner on the same visit. It is a practical choice if you want local seafood but do not feel like a long sit-down meal.