Best Italian Food in Winter Park, FL (2026): 6 Local Picks

Looking for the best Italian food in Winter Park? Park Avenue has most of it, from Grappolo's daily fresh pasta to Prato's seasonal cooking and long bar, Pannullo's pizzas facing Central Park, and Rocco's Italian Grille for a dinner with live music.

6 picks · Updated October 2026

1
Grappolo Cucina Italiana

Restaurant in Park Avenue
Fresh pasta made every day and a traditional à la carte menu on South Park Avenue, bookable through OpenTable, make this a reliable Winter Park dinner.
- Italian
- Lunch
- Dinner
Call Grappolo Cucina Italiana Website for Grappolo Cucina Italiana (opens in a new tab)Directions to Grappolo Cucina Italiana (opens maps)
2
Prato

Restaurant in Park Avenue
Prato pairs classic Italian cooking with modern technique and seasonal produce on North Park Avenue, with a long bar and a weekday happy hour.
- Italian
- Happy hour
- Outdoor seating
- Dinner
Call Prato Website for Prato (opens in a new tab)Directions to Prato (opens maps)
3
Rocco's Italian Grille

Restaurant
Dinner-only with house-made pappardelle, a cocktail lounge and live music Wednesday through Saturday, Rocco's is built for a slow, old-school Italian evening.
- Italian
- Dinner
- Date night
- Live music
Call Rocco's Italian Grille Website for Rocco's Italian Grille (opens in a new tab)Directions to Rocco's Italian Grille (opens maps)
4
Pannullo's Italian Restaurant

Restaurant in Park Avenue, $$
Facing Central Park on Park Avenue, Pannullo's serves 16-inch pizzas and jumbo meatballs with a kids menu and sidewalk seating, a family-friendly classic.
- Italian
- Pizza
- Lunch
- Dinner
Call Pannullo's Italian Restaurant Website for Pannullo's Italian Restaurant (opens in a new tab)Directions to Pannullo's Italian Restaurant (opens maps)
5
The Chapman

Restaurant in Park Avenue
Not strictly Italian, but The Chapman's fresh pasta and artisan cheeses on Park Avenue earn it a place when you want pasta alongside steak or Florida fish.
- Italian
- Steakhouse
- Seafood
- Brunch
Call The Chapman Website for The Chapman (opens in a new tab)Directions to The Chapman (opens maps)
6
Garp & Fuss

Restaurant in Park Avenue
Chicken parmigiana and ricotta-topped meatballs bring red-sauce comfort to this Hidden Garden spot off Park Avenue, which is a good pick when part of the table wants a burger instead.
- Italian
- American
- Burgers
- Cocktails
Call Garp & Fuss Website for Garp & Fuss (opens in a new tab)Directions to Garp & Fuss (opens maps)

Where to eat Italian in Winter Park

Four of these six picks sit on Park Avenue. Grappolo is on the south end with pasta made fresh daily, Prato is on North Park Avenue with a patio open year-round, and Pannullo's faces Central Park with sidewalk tables. Rocco's is away from the avenue, which makes parking simpler for a dinner-only evening.

For a date, Prato and Rocco's are the strongest settings, with Rocco's adding live music Wednesday through Saturday. Pannullo's is the family pick, with a kids menu and 16-inch pizzas. The Chapman and Garp & Fuss are good compromises for mixed groups, since both pair Italian dishes like fresh pasta or chicken parmigiana with steaks, burgers and seafood.

Tips for Italian dining in Winter Park

Weekend dinners on Park Avenue fill up, so reserve at Grappolo through OpenTable or call ahead elsewhere. Prato and Pannullo's both run weekday happy hours in the late afternoon, which is the easiest way to get a table and an early bite. Street parking on Park Avenue is limited on Friday and Saturday nights, so leave time to circle or use the nearby garages, and consider the patio only after sunset in the summer months.

About this list

Every place here is a locally run business in Orange County with its own website, which we checked for hours, menus and contact details. We leave national chains off our best-of lists and favor places with a clear specialty.

This page covers 6 Italian restaurants in Winter Park. You'll find them in Park Avenue.

About Winter Park

Winter Park sits just north of Orlando and is known for Park Avenue, Rollins College, its chain of lakes and brick streets. The city has a dense cluster of independent restaurants, boutiques, salons and professional offices.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Italian restaurant in Winter Park?

Grappolo Cucina Italiana is the strongest choice for traditional cooking, with pasta made fresh every day on South Park Avenue. Prato is the pick for modern Italian dishes built on seasonal produce, and Rocco's Italian Grille suits a slower dinner with house-made pappardelle and live music later in the week.

Where can I get pizza on Park Avenue?

Pannullo's Italian Restaurant is the go-to for pizza on Park Avenue, serving 16-inch pies and a family pizza meal deal across from Central Park. It has sidewalk, patio and indoor seating, a kids menu and a weekday happy hour, so it works well for families and casual groups.

Which Italian restaurants in Winter Park have outdoor seating?

Prato keeps its patio open year-round on North Park Avenue, Pannullo's has sidewalk and patio tables facing Central Park, and Rocco's Italian Grille has a patio next to its cocktail lounge. Garp & Fuss also has a plant-filled patio in the Hidden Garden. In summer, book later seatings when the heat eases.