Jewelry Stores near me in Winter Park, FL
5 jewelry stores in Winter Park, Florida, each with a direct link, phone number and what they offer. Whether you're buying an engagement ring, repairing a family piece, or selling gold, a little preparation helps.
5 listings · Updated October 2026
Jewelry Stores listings
-
Majestic Jewelers
Jewelry store
Majestic Jewelers is a family-run jeweler on Aloma Avenue in Winter Park that has served individual and corporate clients since 1986.
-
Unique Diamond Boutique
Jewelry store
Unique Diamond Boutique is a Winter Park jeweler with more than 15 years in business that designs custom engagement rings using 3D CAD modeling.
-
Almut Belote Jewelry
Jewelry store
Almut Belote Jewelry is the Park Avenue shop and online store of master goldsmith Almut Belote. Her collections include gemstone rings, solid gold hinged cuffs, men's pieces and a brushed silver line called ORA.
-
Bay Hill Jewelers
Jewelry store
Bay Hill Jewelers is a family-owned jeweler with about twenty years in business and stores on Park Avenue in Winter Park and in Dr. Phillips. It carries bridal and fashion jewelry from designers such as Hearts On Fire, Simon G.
-
Be On Park
Jewelry store
Be On Park is a Park Avenue boutique in Winter Park where owner Emily Dowling Williams curates fine jewelry from designers such as Roberto Coin, Kwiat and Suzanne Kalan.
Jewelry Stores in Winter Park: what we found
This page covers 5 jewelry stores in Winter Park.
What comes up again and again on their menus and websites: Designer fine jewelry and Appraisals.
The longest-running place here has been open since 1986.
Winter Park sits just north of Orlando and is known for Park Avenue, Rollins College, its chain of lakes and brick streets. The city has a dense cluster of independent restaurants, boutiques, salons and professional offices.
How to choose a jewelry store near Winter Park
Whether you're buying an engagement ring, repairing a family piece, or selling gold, a little preparation helps. For diamonds, ask for an independent grading report from a recognized lab, and compare stones by cut, color, clarity and carat weight rather than by store descriptions alone. For lab-grown stones, confirm the disclosure is in writing. Ask whether repairs, sizing and appraisals are done in-house or sent out, how long they take, and how your item is insured while it's in the shop. Get a written receipt that lists metal type, stone details and the return or exchange policy. If you're selling jewelry, get offers from more than one buyer, since prices vary based on how the piece will be resold or melted. Use the listings below to find jewelers in Orlando, Winter Park, Winter Garden and across Orange County, and compare services like custom design, repair, appraisals and buying.
Local tip
Florida law requires stores that don't offer refunds or exchanges to post a clear no-refund notice at the point of sale, so read the posted policy and get it in writing before buying jewelry.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know a diamond's grading is accurate?
Ask for a grading report from an independent gemological lab and check that the report number matches any laser inscription on the stone's girdle. Compare cut, color, clarity and carat weight across stones. If buying a high-value piece, an independent appraiser can review it before or shortly after purchase.
What affects the price of an engagement ring in Orlando?
Price depends mainly on the center stone's size and quality, whether it is natural or lab-grown, the metal type, setting complexity and any custom design work. Lab-grown diamonds typically cost less than natural stones of similar appearance. Ask for an itemized quote that separates the stone and setting.
Where can I sell gold jewelry in Winter Park?
Jewelers, pawn shops and gold buyers all buy jewelry. In Florida, businesses that buy secondhand goods, including jewelry, are generally required to register as secondhand dealers and follow state recordkeeping rules, so expect to show photo ID. Get several quotes and ask how the offer is calculated, such as by weight and purity.
How often should I get jewelry appraised?
Many insurers ask for updated appraisals every few years, since metal and stone values change. Ask your insurance agent what they require. A good appraisal describes the piece in detail, including metal, stone measurements and grades, and states the type of value, such as replacement value for insurance.
Can a jeweler resize or repair my ring the same day?
Simple jobs like basic sizing or cleaning are sometimes done the same day if the jeweler has an in-house bench. Complex repairs, stone setting, or work on platinum or vintage pieces can take longer, especially if sent out. Ask about turnaround time and how the piece is insured while in their care.
Own one of these jewelry stores?
Listings are free. Claim yours to fix your details, add hours and photos, and see how many people view and call you.